Planning Commission

Called to order 7:00 p.m. 7 present 5 motions

The Halifax Township Planning Commission met on March 7, 2011, with Chairman Fred Ford presiding and members Randy Paul, Mark Reed, Bob Artman, and Steve Sipe all present (Sipe arrived shortly after the 7:00 p.m. call to order). Township Solicitor Bruce Warshawsky and Secretary Carolyn Nye also attended. The session focused on stormwater and land development issues across three properties, with multiple residents voicing concerns about property boundaries and drainage in the Lenker subdivision.

  • Lenker Subdivision advanced to final plan consideration (5-0): Attorney Mark Silver and engineer Jim Snyder presented a revised stormwater proposal with larger retention ponds and infiltration measures to address longstanding neighbor complaints about runoff. The changes reduce frontage on some lots. The revised plan is intended to resolve ongoing litigation, and various waivers and engineering calculations will be submitted for Township Engineer review.
  • Neighbors raised concerns over Lenker property lines and road access: Norma Shearer urged close review of property boundaries involving the Mutersbaugh and Sweigard parcels and expressed concern about the applicant's attorney discussing moving a boundary line. Jim Eppley flagged conflicts between the preliminary plan and existing surveys, and questioned whether a road serving Mike Sweigard's property would be eliminated. Chairman Ford read an email from Sweigard raising stormwater concerns.
  • Conflicting sealed descriptions on Mutersbaugh property: Steve Sipe pressed Jim Eppley on two conflicting sealed legal descriptions for the Mutersbaugh parcel and raised concern about water discharging over a 40-foot right-of-way on that property.
  • Lebo Trust subdivision plan accepted for review (5-0): A new subdivision plan from the Lebo Trust was unanimously accepted to begin formal review. Flo Mallonee asked for clarification on the scope of the proposed subdivision.
  • Morris Rill notified of land development and stormwater requirements (5-0): Engineer Tom Wilson determined that Rill's project — involving 6,000 square feet of impervious coverage — meets the definition of a land development and requires a stormwater management plan. The commission recommended the Board of Supervisors send Rill a formal letter requiring submission of a full land development and stormwater plan if his project goes beyond basic sedimentation control.

Fred Ford (Chairman) · Randy Paul (Planning Commission Member) · Mark Reed (Planning Commission Member) · Bob Artman (Planning Commission Member) · Steve Sipe (Planning Commission Member) · Bruce Warshawsky (Township Solicitor) · Carolyn Nye (Township Secretary)

Norma Shearer — Asked the Board to carefully review the Lenker plan and pay close attention to property lines involving Mutersbaugh and Mike Sweigard; expressed concern about Mark Silver's comments regarding moving the property line.
Jim Eppley — Alerted the Board to discrepancies between preliminary plans and surveys, questioned which was correct, and raised concern about whether the road leading to Mike Sweigard's property would be eliminated from the development.
Fred Ford — Read Mike Sweigard's email stating his concerns regarding the stormwater plan.
Flo Mallonee — Asked for clarification on the subdivision of the Lebo Trust Plan.
Steve Sipe — Asked Jim Eppley for clarification on the Mutersbaugh property regarding two conflicting sealed descriptions, and raised concern about water discharging over the 40-foot right-of-way on the Mutersbaugh property.

APPROVED MINUTES

February 7, 2011 Minutes

Randy Paul made a motion to approve the minutes as written, seconded by Mark Reed. Motion carried 4-0.

planning
4-0 Approve the minutes as written
Moved by Randy Paul

OLD BUSINESS

Lenker Subdivision Plan

Attorney Mark Silver and Engineer Jim Snyder presented a revised stormwater proposal with larger retention ponds and infiltration measures to address runoff concerns raised by the Board and public. The revised plan reduces frontage on some lots and is intended to resolve ongoing litigation; various waivers will be requested and calculations provided for Township Engineer review. Bob Artman motioned to accept the items as proposed and put forth as a final plan for further consideration, seconded by Steve Sipe; motion carried 5-0.

subdivisionstormwaterland-development
5-0 Accept the items as proposed and be put forth as a final plan for further consideration
Moved by Bob Artman

NEW BUSINESS

Lebo Trust Plan

Mark Reed made a motion to accept the Lebo Trust Plan for review, seconded by Bob Artman. Motion carried 5-0.

subdivisionland-development
5-0 Accept the plan for review
Moved by Mark Reed
Morris Rill – Land Development and Stormwater Management Determination

Tom Wilson reviewed his March 3, 2011 memorandum and the E&S Plan prepared by Burch Associates, determining that the plan falls under the land development definition and that 6,000 square feet of impervious coverage requires a stormwater management plan. The landowner indicated he does not intend to build structures. Bob Artman motioned to recommend the Board of Supervisors send a letter notifying Mr. Rill that a land development and stormwater management plan must be submitted if he intends to do more than a sedimentation control plan, seconded by Mark Reed; motion carried 5-0.

land-developmentstormwater
5-0 Recommend to the Board of Supervisors that a letter should be sent to Mr. Rill putting him on notice that a land development and stormwater management plan be submitted if he intends to do more than a sedimentation control plan
Moved by Bob Artman

PUBLIC COMMENT

Public Comment

Norma Shearer asked the Board to carefully review property lines involving Mr. Mutersbaugh and Mike Sweigard. Jim Eppley raised concerns about conflicting preliminary plans and surveys, and questioned whether the road to Sweigard's property would be eliminated. Fred Ford read Mike Sweigard's email with concerns about the stormwater plan. Flo Mallonee asked for clarification on the Lebo Trust Plan subdivision. Steve Sipe asked Jim Eppley about conflicting sealed descriptions on the Mutersbaugh property and water discharge over a 40-foot right-of-way.

subdivisionstormwaterproperty

ADJOURNMENT

Adjournment

Randy Paul made a motion to adjourn, seconded by Steve Sipe. Motion carried 5-0.

5-0 Adjourn
Moved by Randy Paul

This page is an automated summary of official township records. For the authoritative version, always refer to the original document.